Penn Jillette on Capitalism, Magic and Morality

Share on Facebook: Tweet:

Hear the full interview:

Penn Jillette, H.L. Mencken research fellow at the Cato Institute, is the louder, bigger half of the magic/comedy team Penn & Teller. He and Teller co-host a series on Showtime that looks to debunk junk science, scares and scams with reason and logic.

Interview by Caleb O. Brown. Video produced by Caleb O. Brown, Austin Bragg and Evan Banks.

Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 99,979
Added: 3 years
Runtime: 16:14
Comments: 783

Tags for this video:  

Find more videos in the: "News"
Uploaded by: catoinstitutevideo
See more videos uploaded by catoinstitutevideo

Related Videos:

Penn Jillette discusses health care on FOX's Glenn Beck
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 212012
Cato Institute Fellow Penn Jillette and John Stossel join Glenn Beck to discuss health care, the nanny state, Canada and more.
U.S. Senator Rand Paul Speaks at Cato University 2011
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 4397 U.S. Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) spoke at this year's Cato University on everything from national...
"The Baby Boom" (featuring the author, P.J. O'Rourke)
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 2940
Follow the link below to watch the full event: Featuring the author P. J. O'Rourke, H. L. Mencken Research...
P.J. O'Rourke on the new "Obamamobile" at the Cato Institute
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 12236
Government might bring America's love affair with the car to an untimely end. That from P.J. O'Rourke, Cato Institute Mencken research fellow and...
Bill Maher on Feminism
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 101977
Bill comments on Feminism
Penn and Teller Bullshit - College Part 1 of 2
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 280171
Penn and Teller explain why college is pure BULLSHIT!!!!
Civility lesson with an atheist and a priest
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 25853
As budget tensions begin on Capitol Hill, we wonder if Democrats and Republicans can ever find a way to talk to each other. Penn Jillette and...
Authors@Google: Penn Jillette
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 72840
Penn Jillette visited Google's Santa Monica office on August 19, 2011 to discuss his book "God No! Signs You Already May Be an Atheist and Other...
Why Not Even SARAH SILVERMAN Trashes Muslims - Penn Point
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 277934
Looking for more tricks to show off? Check out Scam School with Brian Brushwood: Penn lets you in on the alarming details behind...
Penn Jillette Explains His Libertarian Philosophy
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 161459
From Real Time With Bill Maher, October 14, 2011.
Penn Point - WHY Are Politicians Christian?
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 43433
Looking for more tricks to show off? Check out Scam School with Brian Brushwood: It's not just Michelle Bachmann and Rick Perry!...
Glenn Beck: Penn Jillette on Ron Paul
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 52318
Penn Jillette speaks on the OTHERS candidates for the presidential race!
Penn reminds us why Libertarians are awesome.
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 299846
Video Note: Penn discusses (rants) about the illogical corn subsidies in America. I happen to agree with Penn on this specific issue but I am...
Penn Jillette on God, No!, Atheism, Libertarianism, & More
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 321758
Reason's Nick Gillespie talks with the one-and-only Penn Jillette about his best-selling new book, God, No!: Signs You May Already Be an Atheist...
Jon Stewart's 19 Tough Questions for Libertarians!
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 299913
Stefan Molyneux, host of Freedomain Radio, responds to 19 tough questions for libertarians. Get more from Stefan Molyneux including books, podcasts...
Piers Morgan Is A Dick To Penn Jillette (Part 1 of 2)
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 1618249
Piers Morgan Tonight, CNN, 8-16-2011, Penn Jillette, "Penn talks about being attacked in his Piers Morgan interview":...
Penn Jillette: Voting For Lesser Of Two Evils Always Leads To More Evil
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 61435
Penn on Fox News' Hannity 5/23/12 LIKE- Penn talks about Obama's hypocrisy, Romney, libertarianism, Ron Paul,...
Recycling is BULLSHIT
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 108542
Penn Jillette: Camera Tricks Are Not Magic
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 445876
Don't miss new Big Think videos! Subscribe by clicking here: When the Penn watches televised magic, he has "a very real...
Glenn Beck talks to Penn Jillette, author of "Every Day is an Atheist Holiday! More Magical Tales"
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating
Views: 549859
Atheist & Magician Penn Jillette meets with Glenn Beck. His new book "Every Day is an Atheist Holiday!: More Magical Tales from the Author of God,...
Penn Jillette: Reading the Bible (Or the Koran, Or the Torah) Will Make You an Atheist
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 1072671
Don't miss new Big Think videos! Subscribe by clicking here: The magician was asked to leave his Christian youth group by a...
Even If You LOVE Obama, Here's Why You Shouldn't - Penn Point
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 159221
Looking for more tricks to show off? Check out Scam School with Brian Brushwood: Assuming Obama is the PERFECT president, Penn...
Penn Jillette on Real Time (20111014)
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 22754
No copyright infringement intended. For review purposes only.
Penn Jillette: Why Tolerance Is Condescending
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 928568
Don't miss new Big Think videos! Subscribe by clicking here: Religion can cause "good people to do bad things," but Penn...
"38 Years of Magic and B.S.: A Conversation with Penn & Teller" - TAM 2012
Rating Rating Rating Rating Rating 
Views: 313172
Matt Donnelly interviews Penn & Teller about their career and the influence of skepticism -- and James Randi -- upon it. Live on stage from TAM 2012.


Author Jay Lemoyne (4 months)
Penn Jillette should be regarded as an idol to anyone with an above average
IQ, who believes in facts and not non sense fairy tales. And someone who
thinks logically. If you study what he talks about, and really understand
what he's saying. He is on the right side of every debate. Like any
intelligent, logical human being should be. Only difference with him is he
is famous and can publicly speak to millions at once. 

Author Francesco Santora (5 months)
Oh Penn, as a guy who literally grew up at the Booth School of Business I
gotta tell you: You've been Punked. that punishment reward flip is soo old
and so wrong. This is not the forum but it's an all wood floats therefore
all that floats is wood argument.

Author John Squires (2 days)
Penn is just an ass. He's lost respect from former fans, now he's using
atheism to pull a few more bucks in from the fringe. It may work, I don't
know. It's all he has sad.

Author ian butler (1 month)
Libertarianism is about the rich keeping their wealth and fucking everyone
else. It is a recipie for social ruin and titanic failure. If you think
that it is in any way a message for contemporary society you are unhinged.

Author johannes falcone (4 days)
you cant be a libertarian and vote democrat

Author Patrick Dyer (2 months)
"This is how the skeptic community should deal with women. WHAT?!?!"

Author Leena Circle Page (4 months)
Exactly. They're DUMBER as its gets because of being DUMB. :) :)

Author Mark Collins (10 months)
My atheist hero and my libertarian hero.

Author J macho (3 months)
fuck ALL the clubs Jillette...and even up that shit on yo chin!

Author J macho (3 months)
I am NOT a handsome man-Penn

Author ImA Real (1 year)
Penn Jillette is an intelligent and entertaining fellow and a master at his
craft. He expresses a compassionate and somewhat tolerant attitude. He
seems to be a genuinely likable man. He has displayed some stubbornness
and pride as do we all. I applaud his rational embrace of the Libertarian
politico, but do not understand how being an atheist is such a large part
of who he is. The first question in the interview was about being an

The things I oppose and the things I embrace define me, not the things I
believe or do not believe. Like most people, I do not even think about
most of the things I believe or do not believe unless some new evidence
comes along or someone brings it up in a conversation. For example, I am
sure Penn Jillette believes the Pythagorean Theorem. He does not define
himself by it as did the mystic society that once existed around it.

I don't oppose all the things in which I do not believe; nor do I embrace
all of the things in which I believe. Penn Jillette made it clear that he
opposed, even hated, "magic," a very big part of his life. If he opposes
religion, God, spirituality, and the like or those who embrace them, I
could understand the reason his atheism is such a big part of who he is
and his need to announce it twice in every performance; but he claims NOT
to oppose them. Garth Brooks embraces Christianity. Embracing a disbelief
is absurd.

I don't believe in "magic" but enjoy watching illusionists perform. I
enjoy watching and trying to figure out the "trick", but do not oppose or
embrace "magic" like Penn Jillette does; I don't give it much thought. I
believe in energy and forces that I cannot see, because I am convinced the
evidence or the argument for it is sufficient. I am more interested in
learning what is true, rather than wasting energy trying to prove something
is not true or that someone else is wrong, unless I embrace or oppose that
argument as a primary part of my identity or I feel that my safety and
well-being depend upon it. Trying to prove a negative is an exercise in
futility. That is why our constitution does not require that you prove you
are innocent.

I embrace Christianity. I do not oppose atheists. I am convinced the
knowledge of God is innate within every human being. It can be repressed,
ignored, rejected, etc. The job of Christians is not to criticize or
condemn atheists and non-believers. It is to be an example and share the
love of God with them, just like Jesus did. It was the hypocrites Jesus
criticized, not the uninitiated. If love is not your motivation, you are
not a Christian, but a wolf in sheep's clothing. Christians do not hate
atheists. They do not wish them harm. They simply love them, because they
deserve it.

Author sleedolfine15 (1 year)
The great depression was the inevitable outcome of the fed's easy credit
policy during the 1920s,a policy which led to a credit driven boom. The
inflation of the money supple during this period led to an unsustainable
boom in both asset prices & capitol goods. The fed belatedly tightened
monetary policy in 1928,but too late to avoid a significant contraction.
Afterwards,the economic interventionism of both Hoover and FDR
lenghtened(17years)this depression. History repeats itself.

Author Nytza (1 year)
Communism does not necessarily fit for everyone. But if there is a complete
absence of free trade or Capitalism, then that IS Communism. If people
believe that some free trade should not exist, these are Socialist
programs. When people despise capitalism, I assume they do not want any of
it. Similar to people in belief of gun control. The majority of gun control
activists do not like guns as a whole, it's generalized. Really, it's quite
sad that this recycled comment keeps alive.

Author Brian Hayek (1 year)
You're just like the god of the HOLEY bible. 100% crazy fucking asshole.

Author Brian Hayek (1 year)
Do you even read every comment i make? I told you why SOCIALIZED with a Z
is a failure in the united states. 125 trillion in unfunded SS
medicare/caid prescription drug liabilities and growing by multi trillion a
year. Without SS its still over 100 trillion unfunded. Economic
calculations under any form of socialism are impossible.All forms of
socialism fail just like it will in the united states and sooner than u
think. Walk away from the liberal non sense.

Author Riasat Khan (1 year)
Are you talking about him not believing in psychics??

Author TheRiiiight (1 year)
"there will always be things for the people to do." You state it as if it's
a fact. During the great depression did the people just starve and sit
around because they were stupid? When you're unemployed and broke and
everyone around you is unemployed and broke what are you going to do? You
have no capital to start a business and if you did you'd have almost no
customers who could afford anything. That's the perfect recipe for a
violent communist take over like early 20th century Russia.

Author burnhippiesforfuel (1 year)
the machines give us time to do other things. it allows labor to go toward
things we wouldn't otherwise to work on.

Author lec0621 (1 year)
In other words, you believe that an unbiased analyst can somehow, magically
make biases in the raw data disappear? DId I get this right? If so, you
know nothing of statistical analysis. Sporadic outliers can be sometimes
ignored but bad data yields faulty analysis. Every time. As far as your
second paragraph, it's hogwash. If someone can prove psychic abilities,
Randi's million would be chickenfeed. Such a person would probably not even
challenge Randi. Instant fame + fortune.

Author Robvern M (1 year)
On capitalism there are two books that I found changing, for those that
like to read try these Clive Hamilton and Richard Denniss' book, Affluenza:
When Too Much is Never Enough, and The Life You Can Save: Acting Now to End
World Poverty by Peter Singer. These books changed my thinking regarding
economics and money, which enable my wife and I to be self funded retires
at 40. We both had average income jobs.I HAVE NOT AFFILIATION WITH EITHER
BOOK OR THE AUTHORS. We now travel the world for fun.

Author guyboy625 (1 year)
No, it's perfectly reasonable not to believe in psychics if you have no
evidence for them. Randi pretends to be open to evidence for psychic
ability, but in fact he's far from it, as seen in the way he dismissed
Sheldrake's dog experiment. Understandable, since it would make him lose a
million dollars. What he's good at is deceiving people, and making sure
other people don't deceive him, but he's not good at science. His whole
"prize" cannot be taken seriously from a scientific point of view.

Author guyboy625 (1 year)
Randi lies in the service of what he *thinks* is the truth. He has a
preconceived notion of reality and refuses to have his mind changed. This
is what sets him apart from scientists, who have the humility to confront
their own fallibility.

Author JtK27 (1 year)
I figure that the harm in depriving people who need the help is much
greater than the harm that the fakers cause. The monetary loss is temporary
and arbitrary, the person having to live with constant pain or disability
can't be repayed in anyway if deprived proper care.

Author mikebri527 (1 year)
And you still haven't given me your sources for your net job loss numbers.
Are you just repeating more left wing talking points? If you're going to
state facts then site your source. If not, then leave them out. I have no
time to deal with amateurs that don't know facts.

Author mikebri527 (1 year)
So you mean to tell me that all the people that were building carriages to
be pulled behind horses just shriveled up and died when the automobile was
created? I can't believe that was the case. They (like those whos jobs were
replaced by machines) found employment elsewhere.

Author jshalom65 (1 year)
The Federal Reserve is NOT the government ! It is a private,for profit
organization that is wholly unconstitutional.

Author awakennomore (1 year)
Arizona loves guns, perform here.

Author JtK27 (1 year)
*seeing as the systems...

Author canteluna (1 year)
"I never said it was the only goal. Stop putting words in my mouth." & I
never said that you said it was the only goal. "So you mean to tell me that
all the people that were building carriages to be pulled behind horses just
shriveled up and died when the automobile was created?" You wouldn't be
trying to put words in my mouth would you?

Author Gordon Bradley (1 year)
Value ? Then why do we have an advertising industry ? What does it achieve
exactly ? Billions spent on conning dummys into buying overpriced crap ?
Surely not.

Author gogothewind123 (1 year)
I would also remind you that that was a period of mass use of child labour,
over exploitation of resources both natural and human, urban squalor,
corruption, social injustice and generally not caring if the poor lived or
died. Then we introduced socialised medicine, education, welfare, market
regulations and labour unions which hugely improved standard of living and
life expectancy for those who needed it most. Would you look at that,
government is more effective than unconnected individuals.

Author bob along (1 year)
Where I wonder do you get your info. Do you pull it straight out of your
ass? Or is it from the NRA's web site? Our murder rate is 4 times that of
England. England 1.2 per 100,000 vs. US 4.8. ??? We are in the bottom half
of the stats. Just keep making up shit, it really helps your argument..

Author sleedolfine15 (1 year)
The great depression was caused by government and kept going for 17 years
by interventionist economic policies. Speaking of starvation,the New Deal
actually destroyed food to artificially keep farm prices high. People
weren't stupid,but it's hard to help oneself when your government is waging
war against you. We didn't have a violent communist revolution. What we got
instead was corporatism which is a variation of fascism.

Author what (1 year)
Wizards are not renowned for their physical appearance.

Author JtK27 (1 year)
What you're saying is basically: "If we didn't allow corruption there would
be no corruoption". Neither money or goverment are inherently corrupt. But
they're forms that allow people to gain disproportionate amounts of power.
I think that we need both markets and goverment. And a lot of informed
citizens that are able to involve themselves in the politics of it all.

Author JtK27 (1 year)
Haha, that made me smile.

Author Ryan Ferretti (1 year)
If a man starts at 50 grand, & invests & grows that money into 600 million
dollars, at what point is anyone else other than him, entitled to the net
amount of his earnings? I always hear liberals talk about how certain
people have so much and should give it to those who need it. Sure, life is
unfair. Some people end up with much more due to luck, better genetics,
etc. etc., but, that fact doesn't mean anyone is entitled to one penny out
of the millions. They did nothing to generate that wealth.

Author robonez (1 year)
Tonight I have watched 3 Penn Jillette-interviews and 4 Gene
Simmons-interviews. Not planned at all, these things just popped up,
probably based on things I've watched before or something. I was a huge
Kiss-fan for many years, and I dig Penn and Teller. The thing that I'm left
with though, after these interviews, is that Penn Jillette is brilliant,
and Gene Simmons is a retard.

Author Brian Hayek (1 year)
Part 3. When politicians have omnipotent like power the first things that
will be bought and sold are the politicians. If what you said is true the
American middle class would have never existed. The middle class existed
because the united states is the closest thing to laissez-faire that has
ever existed. You may as well be bragging that government has broken the
legs of the poor and middle class and has handed them crutches. Without
government they couldn't walk! Without government they could

Author Harmon Bean (1 year)
yepp! i think america needs people like them further up in the "system"
personally it would be amazing to even just hear those 3 have a

Author JtK27 (1 year)
I get your point. However when you look at a country like Sweden where
there is a mixed market economy you'll get the "best of both worlds". I
seriously don't believe that there's much difference between a communist
dictatorship and capitalist one. In the end you'll end up with a system
that totally disregard human life, seeing at the systems get
"self-serving". Socialism isn't necessarily "slavery" and capitalism isn't
necessarily "freedom". It's much more complex that that.

Author mikebri527 (1 year)
The bottom line is that we as consumers understand one very important word:
VALUE. We typically will not pay ridiculously high prices for inferior
products. We prove that time and time again with our purchasing habits.
Manufacturers know this and have to react to it. All that being said, I
still say that it's better for a lot of people to pay lower prices for
goods then to have a few people get high wages. And again the best example
is the unions at GM and Chrysler.

Author Brian Hayek (1 year)
And you have the authority to deem people "fucks"? I don't think someone
who believes in fictional hell has the mental capacity to properly judge
people. Such a short snide comment tells a lot about you without even
knowing you.

Author Nytza (1 year)
Just look at Disability now. It is the most perverted and abused social
system in the United States. It requires almost nothing to receive it. My
girlfriend's mother has been on it for many years for "back problems". She
moves around fine. If we noticed that there was a problem with disabled
people in our nation, charities would rack up, and many would compete to
earn the profit that some of them decide to take. It's impossible to do
when you make the entire country poorer with forced services.

Author Brian Hayek (1 year)
Part 3. If morally you can not accept to see the suffering of others GET
READY to help ease it. Americans will learn what real poverty is during ur
life. Gold Guns and Gardens. He who saves one life saves the world entire.
You may not believe the reality i have just told you but u wont be able to
ignore the consequences of ignoring reality. The united states government
is a snake eating itself and we should be glad it will DIE because of its
own corruption.While i live let me have a FREE COUNTRY

Author Brian Hayek (1 year)
Depression and unemployment are not caused by laissez-faire. These are
things caused by government. What you state is great myth and some is not
even placed in the right century. Socialized medicine came about in the
20th century and it has been a great failure. Unless you think ponzi
schemes are sweet. Socialism never works at anything. The united states has
125 trillion in unfunded SS medicare/caid prescription drug libabilities
and growing by multi trillion a year.

Author jshalom65 (1 year)
Okay,I'll cop to that,but that's part of the deceipt of it,it has the
patina,the veneer of federality and gov't.sanction,which is the tip of the
iceberg hiding the grave danger that lies beneath,the greed, the
amorality/immorality and blind worship of money,the parasitic
UNCONSTITUTIONAL money mafia that has been. allowed to have it's merry
lootingly destructive way way for nearly 100 years.The results have been
the great depression,every recession,2008,everyone overextended on

Author Scott Fulton (1 year)
to blindly go forth into the future without learning for mandkinds past
mistakes is narrow minded

Author MrJustice01 (1 year)
Machines do work, but there is always job for operators. In a theoretically
perfect economy no one has to work, just to push a few buttons and we have
everything we want. Your arguments against the machines is the same that
people used during the industrial revolution.

Author canteluna (1 year)
"Families don't make enough because of inflation which is caused by the Fed
and poor gov't monetary policy." You asked others to support their
assertions, why don't you do the same. What is the empirical evidence for
your claim? If you can't prove that before the Fed existed families made
"enough" then your position is a non sequitur.

Embed Video:


Search Video

Top Videos

Top 100 >>>


Check PR